The 4 Best Comforter Sets, Tested by BHG

Feb 23, 2025

We independently evaluate all of our recommendations. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

Create a cohesive bedscape with these comforter sets.

In This Article

Better Homes & Gardens

Your comforter and sheets set can be the difference between a good night’s sleep or a restless night spent kicking the covers off the bed. If you’re thinking about overhauling your bedding, a comforter set can make it easy because they include all you need to transform your sleeping space.

“Whether you routinely place your comforter aside at the end of the night or bundle up with your set each night, a comforter should be soft and comfortable,” says Dahiana Pena, an interior designer.

“High quality materials such as Egyptian cotton, silk, and even cashmere are some of the best and worth the investment," she says. "Natural fibers, including cotton and linen, are also safe and often sustainable options for the bedroom.”

For this article, we tested comforters based on quality, texture, and breathability. For more information on how we tested comforter sets, check out our testing process below.

The bedding set gives the same fluffy, luxury feel as a hotel comforter.

The comforter was a bit noisy while tossing and turning.

For those looking for a comforter set with sheets, this seven-piece option from Better Homes & Gardens is our top pick after testing. We love that this set is well-constructed, with a fluffy, well-distributed fill that didn’t clump or move, even after washing.

The comforter fill is made of polyester, and the shell is a blend of cotton and polyester. Initially, it felt pretty dense and stiff, but thankfully it loosened and softened fairly quickly. It was soft enough that we could skip using a top sheet, if necessary, and it gave us the feeling of a hotel comforter: fluffy and luxurious.

Though the fabric was cool to the touch, the comforter itself kept us warm (but not overly so) during testing. The material also impressed us by being toddler-friendly—spills from children washed out completely without staining the fabric. We did find that the material did make some noise while tossing or turning.

We love that this comforter set is affordable, especially considering that it comes with two pillow shams, a fitted sheet, a top sheet, and two pillow cases. It’s available in white crinkle, green, green stripe, and beige.

Product Details: Size: Queen: 92 inches x 96 inches, king: 110 x 96 inches | Material: Fill: polyester, shell: 50% cotton, 50% polyester | Number of Pieces Included: Seven

It’s lightweight and effective at temperature regulation.

We wished there were more neutral colors to choose from.

After testing, we chose the Downluxe lightweight solid comforter set as the best comforter set for someone looking for a budget-friendly way to upgrade their bedding.

This three-piece comforter set includes a comforter and two reversible pillow shams, which we found to be well-constructed, with simple yet solid seams that held up after washing. When we felt the comforter initially after opening the packaging, we thought it might be too thin to regulate temperature effectively, but we experienced the opposite.

In fact, we found that we stayed comfortable throughout the night. Though we didn’t test this comforter in the summer, we felt that it was lightweight and breathable, and would be a great comforter for warmer months since it isn’t heavy.

This comforter set is available in 29 reversible colors and patterns, including gingham, plaid, stripes, and chevron. This gives a lot of variety, but we wished that there were more neutral pattern choices to choose from.

The comforter, which is made out of polyester and brushed microfiber, felt soft to the touch and cozy. Its sewn-through construction kept the fill evenly distributed and we didn’t have to refluff it at all during our testing period. It even kept its shape after washing and drying.

At less than $50, we found that this comforter set is an affordable option for those looking for lightweight, functional bedding.

Product Details: Size: Twin: 66 x 92 inches, queen: 88 x 92 inches, king: 104 x 92 inches | Material: Polyester, polyester blend | Number of Pieces Included: Three

This affordable comforter set is available in nearly 40 colors.

When testing, this comforter required more than one cycle to get it completely dry.

On top of being breathable and comfortable, the Bedsure comforter set is available in 39 colors, so there’s an option for every bedroom style.

This comforter set comes with three pieces, and the comforter has loops on each of the corners, so that it can also be used as a duvet insert as well. The filling, which is made of polyester, is consistent throughout and evenly spread—there were no air pockets or inconsistent comfort.

Even after laundering, we found that the comforter not only looked exactly the same as when first used, but it also felt exactly the same. In fact, after use, we found that the comforter looked even better than when it first arrived.

The polyester shell is soft and smooth to the touch. If you’re the kind of sleeper who doesn’t prefer a top sheet, we found that this comforter was comfortable enough against bare skin that you could go without.

While testing, we found that it would be best to wash this comforter before use, as it initially felt a bit stiff to the touch, but after the first wash, the texture of the fabric became even softer over time.

We love the approachability of this comforter set. In addition to coming in 39 colorways to suit different styles and preferences, it is also priced at under $50, providing cozy luxury for all budgets. We did find that this comforter, though lightweight, required extra drying cycles before it was thoroughly dried.

Product Details: Size: Twin: 68 x 88 inches, full: 82 x 86 inches, queen: 90 x 90 inches, king 104 x 90 inches, California king: 104 x 96 inches | Material: Polyester | Number of Pieces Included: Three

This set comes with three decorative pillows and a bed skirt for a complete look.

During testing, we found that the fabric of this comforter was a bit rough.

If you’re looking for a faux silk comforter set to lend some luxury to your bedroom, the Madison Park Amherst Collection Faux Silk Comforter is an ideal choice for the job.

It has everything you need to transform your bedding: two shams, three decorative pillows, a bed skirt, and a comforter. We tested this comforter set in our lab, and were impressed by its consistent filling and durability.

During testing, we found that this comforter is a good all-season choice, as it neither cools nor overheats, and is not too heavy. After tossing and turning beneath the blanket, the fill remained evenly distributed and did not shift, no matter how hard we tossed, turned, or shook the blanket.

Keep in mind that the outer shell of this comforter, which is made of 100% polyester, is not as soft or smooth as actual silk. We found during testing that it is a bit rougher than natural silk.

For those whose goal it is to add texture and dimension to their bedding, it’s a great choice that doesn’t break the bank. It’s also available in several different colors, so you can choose the option that best matches your bedroom style.

Size: Full, queen, king, California king | Material: 100% Polyester | Number of Pieces Included: Seven

Overall, we’ve chosen the seven-piece set from Better Homes & Gardens as our top choice because of its quality construction and luxurious feel. If you’re looking for a budget-friendly comforter, the Downluxe Lightweight Solid Comforter Set is the best affordable comforter set, and it includes two pillow shams and a reversible comforter.

Better Homes & Gardens / Henry Wortock

We tested 63 comforters, and the final four were chosen for this list because they're durable, comfortable, and held up after washing.

Before we got started, we inspected the comforters to see whether they had sewn-through or baffle box-constructions. We also carefully examined the quality of the stitches and made note of any imperfections or loose threads.

Additionally, we spent time examining how high and fluffy the individual sections of fill were. We also examined how the fill was distributed, and whether or not it was thinner in some areas than others.

We did this by pinching the fabric of the comforter to determine whether or not we could feel between the top and bottom layer of fabric, or if there was fill between. If it was the former, it signified that there was less fill, making it a lighter weight comforter. Feeling the fill indicated that the comforter was thicker and heavier.

Naturally, while testing comforters, we spent some time in bed—five minutes, to be exact—lying underneath the comforters to determine how soft they were, and whether or not there were any changes to our body temperature as we did.

We also tossed and turned in bed underneath the comforter, and during that time we noted if the fabric made noise. We also stood up and held the comforter from the side, shaking it 10 times, to test whether or not the fill shifted.

After performing these tests, we ranked each comforter on their quality, breathability, texture, and value.

Comforters are meant to hang over the side of your mattress and keep your sheets from view. Mattress sizes are standard across the board, which means it’s easy once you find the right mattress to find a corresponding comforter size.

Twin-size comforters are typically 66 to 68 inches wide and 86 to 88 inches long. Queen-size comforters are 86 to 88 inches wide and 96 to 100 inches long. Often, they tend to be 90 by 90 inches, in order to meet in the middle.

King-size comforters tend to be wider than they are long, measuring in at 102 inches wide, and 86 to 99 inches long. California king beds need comforters that are 107 to 110 inches wide and 96 to 98 inches long.

If your mattress is thick, you may want to consider a comforter that is either at the top of the size range, oversized, or size up completely, that way there is enough material to overhang.

When it comes to choosing the material of your comforter, there are two factors to consider: The material of the shell, and the filling that is on the inside.

The fabric shell is going to be the visible part of your comforter, so you can play with what fabric fits your style. Common fabrics include cotton, linen, silk, bamboo, flannel, faux fur or suede, microfiber, and sateen. Lighter fabrics like cotton, bamboo, silk or sateen are great for warmer months, while flannels and faux furs are better for cooler months.

Common comforter fill is made down or goose down, cotton, wool, polyester, and synthetic materials. Down is a filling made of feathers and is fluffy and warm while still being lightweight. These comforters are not typically machine washable, so caring for them can be more difficult.

Wool filling is a heavier option so it will keep you warm, and it is also moisture wicking. Cotton is also commonly used as a filling as well. Synthetic materials are also available, which help keep costs down while being lightweight.

Comforter sets can include anywhere from three to 12 pieces. Comforter sets that include three pieces typically come with the comforter itself, plus two matching pillow shams. Sometimes, they will come with four pieces, including a bed skirt. Some also include a duvet cover for your comforter, which are meant to extend the life of the bedding by reducing washing.

Others include sheet sets, which include two pillowcases, a fitted sheet and a top sheet. There are even options for bundles that include pillows, whether they are standard pillows or decorative shams and throw pillows that complete the look of your bedding.

Better Homes & Gardens

With eight pieces including a comforter, two decorative pillows, two standard shams, two Euro shams, and one bed skirt, we found that this comforter set from Threshold was a great value at just $99. Unfortunately, during testing, we felt the fabric was rough, and that the fabric pilled after just one wash.

When we tested this Laura Ashey set—which comes with one comforter, one bedskirt, and two matching pillow shams—we found that it was cozy, yet lightweight enough that we didn’t get overheated. We also love how perfectly it would complement a cottagecore aesthetic. However, we found that the dust ruffle did not hold up, and the comfort was super wrinkled after washing. We felt that it was a smaller size than expected, and wished that it was just a few inches longer.

The Harbor House Anslee three-piece comforter set earned high marks for even fill distribution and overall construction, and we found it to be nice and thick. We didn’t like that laundering required a commercial machine that made it impossible to wash at home in a standard washing machine.

We found the Better Homes & Gardens three-piece gauze comforter set to be well-constructed and breathable. While the lining of the comforter was soft and comfortable, the decorative top fabric felt somewhat rough and itchy. Additionally, we found that the fill became uneven after washing, though drying flat could remedy this issue.

There are a few benefits to getting a comforter set. The first being that you won’t have to worry about finding pillow shams (or sometimes, even sheets) that match or coordinate with your comforter, making it easier to bring a cohesive look to your sleeping space.

Comforters can be kept on your bed all year around, especially because often they aren’t as filled or heavy as duvets can be. This means they’re also the better option for those who tend to get hot.

There are a few factors that determine whether or not a comforter is good quality. While testing comforters in our lab, we did this by examining the stitching on the comforter and whether or not the fill shifted during use.

It’s also important to look at the materials used to make your comforter. Natural fibers like cotton or linen are durable and become softer over time. Bamboo, silk, or sateen are also soft and often more expensive.

Depending on the type of fill used in your comforter, you can check the quality by seeing whether or not it shifts and keeps its shape. Many comforters, like the Buffy Cloud Comforter Set, have a trial period or return policy to be sure you love your comforter.

Typically, baffle-box constructions will have a higher quality and are indicative of the best comforter sets, because it takes more time to make. However, just because a comforter has a sewn-through construction doesn’t mean it’s poor quality—a baffle-box will just feel more luxurious.

In general, comforters can last anywhere from 10 to 20 years. This depends on the material and type of fill, how often you launder your comforter, and whether or not you choose to cover the comforter with a duvet cover.

If you do use a duvet cover, your comforter will require less laundering, as your body does not come into direct contact with the comforter. If your comforter looks thin, fill starts to escape from the comforter, or material begins to fray, it’s time to replace it.

Andrea Wurzburger is a writer at Better Homes & Gardens who loves to research, test, and try new products and has covered such topics as bedding, towels, and appliances. For this story, she spent several hours researching the best comforter sets by comparing product reviews, customer recommendations, and product specifications. She also spoke with interior designer Dahiana Pena about what to look for in comforter sets.

Next to all of the products on this list, you may have noticed our BHG Recommends seal of approval. Products that earn the seal have been put through rigorous testing to make sure they're worth a spot in your home. We buy most of the products we test ourselves, but occasionally we are provided samples by companies if buying isn't an option. In these cases, we use the same testing criteria we use to test the purchased products.